I have been contemplating for a long time what to do with Addelynn waking up during the night. When she was first born she would wake up a few times a night to feed, but by several months (once she doubled her body weight) she no longer woke up because of hunger.
For the past several months Josh and I get up anywhere from 1-5 times a night to put Addelynn's pacifier back in her mouth or pat her back to soothe her back to sleep. This at times has made us both tired and grumpy. As I think about it it's kind of selfish to say that as some parents are still waking up for long periods of time with their infants. We don't have to take her out of her crib and two seconds after we pat her or give her her pacey she is fast asleep again. I have had several friends try and have success with cry it out method and to be completely honest I have never felt comfortable with the concept. Addelynn does not get calmer or more tired, but more agitated and harder to get to sleep when she is left to cry.
Anyways, so as a new parent I have been easily swayed to try this "sleep solver" method. I have a friend who is a psychologist who told me there have been proven studies that this method can cause adverse affects to the child and I listened to her for months because I have been trying to find a solution for months. Well, a few days ago I tried this method (still not feeling good about it)Addelynn woke up about an hour into her sleep cycle (which after much research over the past several days I have learned that infants transition into their wakeful sleep about every hour during the night, so this makes complete sense). I waited in agony the recommended 5 minutes, which seemed like an hour as my sweet little girl just got more upset in her crib. I went in tried to soothe her as she lay in her crib and when that didn't work, picked her up, patted her, kissed her forehead, put her back down and patted her back some more. She woke up again about 20 minutes later and this time I waited the recommended 10 minutes, same process occured. She finally stopped crying, only to start back up again 5 minutes later. This time I was supposed to wait 15 minutes and 7 minutes into this excruciating process, there was silence. It wasn't comforting silence though, it was very eery and disheartening. I went up to check on her as I was scripting the events to a friend from church on facebook (who agreed I should go check on her :) ). I went in and she had cried (well screamed) herself to sleep.
I haven't felt right about his method and as I type Addelynn is waking up :). I decided to do some research which really helped to reaffirm my feelings. Now, don't get me wrong everyone has their own ways that work for their kids and that they feel is right. I don't feel like the CIO method works for Addelynn and it makes me feel absolutely horrible to do it.
Some researchers likened the method to an adult who is in pain or is having a hard time and their spouse closing the door and ignoring them, others said that the baby does not eventually just soothe themself but more "give up" because they've cried so long and no one has come to comfort them, and finally out of exhaustion fall asleep. While more people have questioned this method, more research has been done about it. After doing my research, I am reverting back to my intuition and doing what I feel is right for my baby. If I have to get up a few times a night for just a few seconds to ensure my baby feels comforted and forms the attachments she should, I really don't mind. Afterall, that's what I signed up for right? I was reading from Dr. Sears (a family of pediatricians with over 30 years experience) that most parents have this preconceived notion that their child has to sleep through the night by a certain age and if they're not then something wrong, when in fact babies cry when they are in need of something. You can't over spoil them. They don't know whether you are in the next room or halfway down the block, all they know is that they're in a jail-like crib, situated in a mostly dark room, all by themselves, and they're scared. They have no notion of where we are. That made me feel so much better for going in there and reassuring her.
Anyways, I am going to post some of the research below that I got from Dr. Sears page. If you know me I research until the point my husband prys me off the computer with frusteration, lol. I hope I don't offend anyone in any way who might read this late night post. I always love when people show me different options or info to back up how I was feeling. To be completely honest most of my friends that have tried the CIO approach say they absolutely hate it, but felt like it was their only option. Anyways, if you are feeling like I did about this whole sleeping mess and are unsure of what to do you can start by googling "is the cry it out method harmful to babies" Here is the research link:
http://www.askdrsears.com/html/10/handout2.asp
As, wierd as it sounds I enjoy rocking my baby to sleep because I have waited all my life to do that. Addelynn will only be little for a short while and I want to savor it, for surely I won't be rocking my ten year old to sleep! Sure, I am grumpy because I don't get alot of sleep sometimes, but the second my baby smiles my heart melts and I forgot any worry that was on my mind.
I wouldn't trade motherhood for anything...and I have decided that even includes the sleepless nights!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
11 comments:
I totally agree! This never worked for Tanner or Parker. After 5 minutes I always go in. Sometimes Parker still wakes up but within a few minutes is back to sleep. If he is crying though my heart just melts and I have to go in! That is the one thing that bothers me about doctors, they immediately think something is wrong with your baby if they don't sleep through the night! You are such a good mother and I am thankful for your loving example!!
Reading your post melts my heart. I am glad you are listening to yourself and not everyone else. You know I agree that they are only little once. I just remembered that when Logan wasn't sleeping we realized that he was afraid of the dark and so we put a little light in his crib so he could see when he woke up and it really helped. Call me if you want a small push light since I have then left from Logan
The Crying It Out method worked for me, and Carissa has never had issues with it. I have to do it, mostly to stay sane, but also because it helped Carissa to soothe herself.Within a couple of days, after crying it out, Carissa did not cry at all and would go right back to sleep. If she woke up in the middle of the night, I would hear one cry, and then she would go right back to sleep. She knows when it is time to go to bed and doesn't make a fuss about it. I think that some things work for some people, but sometimes it's not for everyone. But it did work for us, and I will use it with Macey.Good luck though!
I am glad you are finally feeling good with what you are doing! It is good to have people all around us with different opinions and ideas. How else would we all learn. Now dont' get me wrong, I do enjoy being able to lay down all three of my babies (4,2, and 3 months for those of you reading and wondering if I am insane and have triplets or something) and they have the ability to go to sleep on their own. They all often times wake up, move around a bit, sometimes make some noise (even a little cry or two) then go back to sleep all on their own. You and I have had long extensive talks about this and it may work for me and not for the next person, in this case, you.
To put it into other terms... children coming to sleep in their parents room. Patton comes into my room almost nightly. I used to get up and put him back in his bed every time he got up (this was before my three children/exhaustion stage). I now just roll over, tell him he can sleep on the floor if he likes (kids DO NOT belong in my bed in the middle of the night, unless they are sick or something- even then I am on the couch with them so Jeff can sleep) but he is not getting in my bed. This satisfies what ever need he is having, lays down, and goes to sleep. Now some extremists :) may think this is a "no no" but to be honest I just finally decided that I am NOT going to end up having a 16 year old young man sleeping on my floor so WHO CARES! Half the time he gets up sometime later and gets back in his own bed. I love ya Cort and you are an amazing mom, and Addy is pretty darn cute too:) We will have to shoot for another get together soon. Maybe I can get someone to watch my little ones and head down to your house instead.
i agree too....I hate the CIO method. I've also read that it is completely normal for children up to the age of 2 to not sleep through the night:)
I would have to say that I am a mommy who signed up for sleepless nights...I get tired too but you know my girls woke up a few times a night until they were over 1 and I kept going in and soothing them...Yes I was tired and worn out but they are happy loving girls and I would not do it any different...
Still no Baby Justin yet...I will post as soon as he decides to show up and I have access... Praying it is soon
I still can't let my babies cry themselves to sleep. It just breaks my heart. They also go to sleep a ton faster if they know I'm right there. Amalee was 2 before she was sleeping in her own bed and I could just say good night and walk out the door. It breaks my heart to hear my kids cry. And like you said the moment they smile or laugh you forget the tired part!
You're stronger than I am! I couldn't go through the day after nights I had to check on Britton so many times, so I let him cry. Of course, anything over 5 minutes I'd check on him. While I'm living with my parents and share the same room with him I've had to distinguish between his awake and his sleeping noises. He's been better though, but he definitely doesn't sleep all the way through the night yet. But, my doctors tell me that if they're sleeping for 6 hours straight (not sure if Addelyn is) that's considered through the night. It sure doesn't feel like it to me, but that's what my doc said.
Have you tried other methods to try and help her sleep longer? I found that swaddling Britton kept him from wiggling and squirming himself awake. He also slept better when I have a humidifier on or a noise maker...just some suggestions. Good luck with it!! (and I totally agree with just wanting to hold and rock your baby...gotta do it while you can!!)
good for you for sticking with your gut- you're the mama and know what's best for her and you! Personally I am a "Cry it outer", I give it an hour & a half. within a week it gets shorter and down to 5 minutes in no time. Hayden didn't sleep through the night until 8 months old, because we lived with my parents when he was 2 mo. old until 8 mo. the first week in my house Jeff worked graveyards so it was a breeze, no one else gave in against my demands to stay away. I guess I have a gift for tuning it out or knowing what cry is for what need or want. I had that kid down to an art. His problem was waking up and nursing back to sleep and sharing the bed with me for 8 months. So I learned fast how to get Treston sleeping all night by 2 months. I stick to my Grandma's theory, they are fed, and dry and not hurt, let them cry it's good for their lungs. Personally I don't see any psychological damage being done the 1st 6 months, especially when it comes to sleep patterns. My rarely give me trouble at bedtime because they know that when the door shuts it's staying that way until morning, and I think it's because I instilled it in them before they could throw a fit or be scared. After all they were in a dark uterus for 9 months, a dark room should be soothing! But that's just me & my take on things, good luck on your end! ps they really do grow WAY TOO FAST.
there is no way i could ever let ellie cry herself to sleep either! regardless of what other people think or say, if she is crying, i put her in my bed next to me and she would pass out immediatley. even to this day, she falls asleep next to me and then we put her in her bed. it's not worth having to hear her scream our names. i also enjoyed rocking her to sleep. she is too big for that now! just enjoy her wanting to be held!
I read your post and was trying to decide where I stand. I have never felt really strongly about crying it out being bad for them, but I don't enjoy enforcing it either. I finally realized that I've never had the problem you have! It must be in my kids DNA, but by 2 months they are sleeping through the night and don't wake up that I know of. BUT, for me it was getting them to sleep in the first place. Abbie was really hard and she wouldn't go to sleep in the rocking chair no matter how long I did it, so my last result was to let her learn to put herself to sleep. I love rocking my babies, although they don't typically fall asleep. It was interesting to read your viewpoint and before I tried that method on a baby of mine, I would read the research now that you have brought it up. Good luck!
Post a Comment